A study says that most people wait too long for knee replacement surgery


"When people expect too much, they lose more and more functions and cannot exercise or be active, leaving them exposed to weight gain, depression and other health problems," said lead researcher Hassan Ghomrawi, associate professor of Northwestern University surgery. Feinberg School of Medicine.

Also, the surgery may not be as successful, Ghomrawi said.

"There are several studies that have shown that patients who undergo surgery when their function is severely impaired can improve a lot, but their improvement is not yet average," Ghomrawi said. "They fall behind in optimal benefit."

On the other hand, the study also found that 25% of people who opt for knee surgery receive it too soon, run significant risks, including possible complications, while potentially incurring the cost of major surgery without obtaining an additional benefit. in mobility

"There are a million knee surgery procedures that occur in the United States every year," Ghomrawi said, "and 25% of them are premature. That's a lot of patients."

Because artificial knees wear out after about 20 years, early users also prepare for another knee replacement later in life, said Ghomrawi, which is generally a much harder surgery with a worse outcome than the original.

An objective algorithm

The study, published Monday in the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, followed more than 8,000 people with symptoms of knee osteoarthritis for up to eight years.

While other studies have looked at people who underwent the knife, it is believed that this study is the first to examine the opportunity of knee replacement among people who could benefit from the procedure, Ghomrawi said.

Lifestyle changes can fight a dementia that affects people between 40 and 50 years old.
The study applied an objective measure to determine the "ideal time" of knee replacement. He used an algorithm first developed in Europe in 2003, then updated in 2014 by researchers from the Commonwealth of Virginia who analyzed data from a smaller study of 200 people and discovered that a third party underwent surgery too soon.

"There are 16 unique combinations that can be assigned according to age, knee stability and if the patient has mild, moderate, intense or intense pain," Ghomrawi said.

Knee stability is defined as the ability not only to bend, but also how "wavy" the knee is due to loose tendons, and also takes into account the sounds of clicking and grinding.

In addition, the measurement analyzes the severity of osteoarthritis on radiographs, "if it is bone on bone", as well as how many parts of the knee are affected: the femur (thigh bone), the tibia (tibia) and the patella (kneecap) ).

After factoring all these elements, Ghomrawi and his team assigned the patients in the study to three categories: on time: they underwent surgery within two years after the replacement became potentially appropriate; delayed: no surgery or surgery you waited until after those two years; and premature

The cost of premature surgery.

This is not the first study to try to apply an objective criterion to what has been a traditionally subjective conversation between a patient and a doctor. The National Health Service of the United Kingdom commissioned a study last year to see if they could apply objective measures to the decision.
The effort is due in part to the cost: in the United Kingdom, the cost can vary from 11,000 pounds ($ 14,300) to 15,000 pounds ($ 19,467) and, according to a 2015 study, if there are complications or the surgery must be redone, you can increase to 75,000 pounds ($ 97,313).
Experts say that the ketogenic diet is not sustainable, so why is it so popular?
In the United States, according to a Blue Cross Blue Shield study, a typical knee replacement surgery can range between $ 12,000 and $ 70,000 depending on the part of the country in which you live.

And then there is the growing popularity of surgery: the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons projects that knee replacements only in the US. UU. They will grow up to 189% over the next decade, for a projected 1.28 million procedures by 2030.

The American population of baby boomers is aging, as are their knees, but those numbers may be partially driven by the increase in knee replacements among those under 65. A 2012 study found that total knee replacement more than tripled for people aged 45 to 64 between 1999 and 2008; For those over 65, it just doubled. The study found that the cost of all these operations was more than $ 9 billion.

Can an objective algorithm work?

Not everyone believes that such an objective approach will succeed in the healthcare environment.

"I would say that this document analyzes the issue from the perspective of experts and not necessarily from the perspective of the patient," said Dr. Bart Ferket, assistant professor of population science and health policies at the Icahn School of Medicine at the Hospital Mount Sinai In New York.

"It's an attempt to objectify things that are subjective," said Mount Sinai orthopedic surgeon Dr. Edward Adler, who, like Ferket, was not involved in the study.

The pain, for example, is subjective and could interfere with the algorithm's ability to assess knee stability and pain levels reported by the patient.

"Some people will allow you to move your knee even though it hurts a lot," Adler said. "They can have a lot of pain, you wouldn't know. They work well."

Wake up, people: according to one study, you are fooling yourself about sleep

"There are other people who have a little pain and everyone around them has to know." "So it's quite subjective as to how much you tolerate before your knee is replaced."

Ghomrawi agrees that there could be excellent subjective reasons why a person could decide to receive an early knee transplant instead of deciding to wait.

A scenario, he says, for a transplant at an earlier age, for example, could come from financial considerations. A candidate for surgery may choose to move forward, thinking: "I am the only financial support for my family; I maintain my functional level so that I can continue to be the support of my family."

Or maybe an older person has a very painful knee, "but they support it because they are taking care of their spouse," Ghomrawi said.

Still, studies show that many people are not happy with the result of their knee replacement; A 2010 study found that almost 20% said they were not satisfied.

Objective or subjective, Adler said there should be a realistic assessment by each person of what a new knee can really achieve. If a person undergoes surgery before the onset of severe or significant pain, the patient may not see sufficient improvement.

"Knee replacements are not really made for tennis and running," he said, "they are made for long distances and daily activities.

"What God gave you is not necessarily the same as I can give you," Adler said, "if your goal is to be normal, it is difficult to get when the knee comes out of a box."