Ratan Tata struggles to save legacy after Mistry Court ruling



(Bloomberg) – After getting his protege off the helm of Tata Sons Pvt. Ratan Tata was looking forward to a partial retirement at a session coup three years ago. Instead, he fights again – this time in court.

India's Supreme Court is expected to hear an appeal by the $ 111 billion conglomerate earlier this week to overturn a body's order, instructing the Tata Group to resign the man she dismissed as chairman adjust. The 82-year-old Tycoon personally leads the charge in this case and filed a separate petition against the verdict.

In a severe blow to the Tata group, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal declared on December 18 that Cyrus Mistry was inappropriately removed in October 2016 at the instigation of Ratan Tata, group emeritus emeritus, whose actions the minority oppressed investors. Meanwhile, Mistry said that he does not want to return, but will fight for the protection of shareholder rights.

The Indian court orders Tata to reinstate It Fired's chairman

The court's ruling threatened to disrupt Ratan Tata's 21-year legacy when the group embarked on unprecedented expansion, buying assets such as the legendary luxury car maker Jaguar Land Rover and British steel maker Corus Group Plc. After Mistry took over as chairman in 2012, he tried to take a few steps back from his predecessor to reduce the group's debt and pulled Ratan Tata into anger, which eventually cost him his job.


"This is a milestone for Ratan Tata," said Sanjiv Bhasin, executive vice president of Mumbai-based Brokerage India Infoline Ltd. "This is an ego fight and he wants to protect his legacy related to the transformation of the Tata group."

The legal battle is the latest challenge for the eighty-year-old at a time when the group is trying to find partners for JLR whose assets have waned following Brexit, a slump in demand in China and a backlash against fossil fuels vehicles. The purchase of Corus in 2007 increased the debt of Tata Steel Ltd. and the company is now reducing its activities in Europe by cutting thousands of jobs.

In his complaint filed on January 2, Tata Sons requested an urgent hearing to cancel the previous appointment. "Any shadow over the management of any of these companies puts the public interest at risk," the petition says. Ratan Tata said one day later in his separate notification that the pre-instrument's judgment was "erroneous, completely incorrect and untenable".

Repressed Tata chairman says he doesn't want his old job back

In a statement on Sunday, Mistry, whose family owns 18% of Tata Sons, said that he would not try to become a director in Tata group companies such as Tata Consultancy Services Ltd., Tata Teleservices Ltd. or Tata Industries Ltd. Executive said he would try to regain his seat on the board of Tata Sons.

"It is time for the management of the group to think and think about their behavior while tackling future measures," he said.

What is the struggle for India's Tata group?

The lower court, which issued the shock order last month, had most of its important decisions changed by the Supreme Court last year. Six of the eight major cases decided in 2019 were reversed or amended by the Supreme Court, a larger proportion than in previous years.

As part of his order, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal decided that the appointment of Natarajan Chandrasekaran to chair Tata Sons in early 2017 was illegal. It also ordered Tata Sons to be reclassified as a public company, giving minority shareholders more autonomy in selling their shares.

It also prevented Tata and his representatives from making decisions that would require a majority on Tata Sons' board.

"It will only be a significant victory for Tata if they receive a blanket Apex Court suspension for the entire decision," said Ramesh K. Vaidyanathan, founder and managing partner of Advaya Legal, a Mumbai-based law firm. "I would consider it a setback for them if they only managed to secure a stay with Mistry & # 39; Resume."

The court that heard Tata Fall often changed his decisions

Tata Sons controls and invests in the most important companies in the group and supervises 28 listed companies. The 152-year-old group employs 700,000 people who manufacture cars, mix tea, forge steel, sell insurance, write software, operate telephone networks and pack salt, among other things.

Ratan Tata, who now heads the Tata Trusts, which control 66% of the Tata sons, had multiplied the group's revenue over the past two decades as chairman.

"I look forward to the coming decade, which is a great time to be relevant, to stand up for things you believe in, to create something from scratch, to make special connections, to laugh and to write a bit of history. " Ratan Tata wrote in an Instagram post on December 28th on the occasion of his birthday.

(Updates with Mistry statement in paragraphs 3, 8 and 9)

Contact the reporters about this story: PR Sanjai in Mumbai at psanjai@bloomberg.net, Upmanyu Trivedi in New Delhi at utrivedi2@bloomberg.net

Contact the editors responsible for this story: Sam Nagarajan at samnagarajan@bloomberg.net, Bhuma Shrivastava

<p class = "Canvas-Atom Canvas-Text Mb (1.0em) Mb (0) – sm Mt (0.8em) – sm" type = "text" content = "For more articles like this please visit us at bloomberg.com"data-reactid =" 46 "> You can find more items of this kind at bloomberg.com

© 2020 Bloomberg L.P.